This post was originally published on this site.
The US government awarded its first commercial deep-sea mining leases off American Samoa for $6 million on Thursday, defying local opposition and proceeding days after a federal judge ruled regulators had failed to adequately assess environmental risks.
The Marine Minerals Administration awarded two 20-year leases covering about 31.5 million acres to deep-sea mining startup Wetstone US Ventures. The company paid the minimum bid of $3 million for each area, making it the only bidder to submit offers despite competition from another registered participant.
“We had hoped it would never come to this,” Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka, an American Samoa resident who has opposed the auction for more than a year, said in a statement Thursday.
“Our people deserve more than being heard and ignored. We deserve a meaningful say in decisions that will affect generations. Ocean rights are human rights, and our home is not for sale.”
The auction advances President Donald Trump’s April 2025 directive to accelerate access to critical minerals on the ocean floor as Washington seeks to counter China’s dominance of mineral supply chains.
Three lawsuits challenging the sales threaten to delay or overturn the leases before commercial extraction begins.
Legal challenges
A federal judge ruled three days before the auction that regulators had failed to fully assess potential harm to protected marine life, including endangered blue, fin, sei and sperm whales, five sea turtle populations and five threatened coral species.
The Marine Minerals Administration said it had responded to the ruling by beginning consultations with the fisheries service on another environmental assessment, but declined to postpone the auction.
The sale proceeded at the Ventura County Fire Department Headquarters in Southern California, where several dozen protesters gathered outside.
American Samoa imposed a moratorium on deep-sea mining in its territorial waters in 2024. Territorial leaders and village councils also opposed federal leasing plans, while most of the more than 76,000 public comments submitted to the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management objected to offshore mining.
In a lawsuit filed Oct. 19, a council of Samoan chiefs, known as matai, and community groups represented by Earthjustice challenged the federal government’s authority to lease seabed areas off the territory.
The plaintiffs argue that the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act and historic treaties with American Samoa do not authorize the Marine Minerals Administration to auction seabed leases in US territories.
A separate lawsuit filed Nov. 18 by Finafinau and the Natural Resources Defense Council seeks to invalidate any leases issued through the auction.
“We will use the full extent of the law to vigorously push for the leases to be voided,” Earthjustice attorney Chris Eaton said in a statement.
Earthjustice represents Fa’asao Amerika Samoa, a group dedicated to protecting the territory’s culture, and the Conservation Council of Hawaii in the litigation.
Heightened interest
The leases allow Wetstone to conduct initial seafloor surveys, explore for minerals and develop testing or mining plans. The company would gain exclusive commercial mining rights in the leased areas only after securing further environmental approvals.
Commercial deep-sea mining remains largely untested worldwide. Although several countries have authorized mineral exploration in their waters, no company has begun commercial production. The US has not issued comparable deep-sea mineral leases since a short-lived mining effort off California more than six decades ago.
The Trump administration is also considering seabed lease auctions near the Northern Mariana Islands, Virginia and Alaska. Separately, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is reviewing applications from companies seeking permits to mine in international waters.